The Gibson Collection: Inside and outside the Skull of Rabbie Burns by Alistair Heather

There are many fascinating and surprising artefacts in the vast trove of the Gibson Collection. I came across one particular piece during a recent rummage that I’d like to bring to your attention. It’s called “Phrenological Development of Robert Burns” and it was published in 1834 in Edinburgh.

This little timepiece transports us to the early 1800s, a time of science and pseudo-science, of enthusiasm and ignorance. The Phrenologists were a group of thinkers who believed that the character and abilities of a person were indicated by the shapes, undulations and abnormalities in the shape of their skull.

This fad came too late for a living Burns to participate in a cranial study consensually. But death was no barrier to the Phrenologists. Burns’ tomb was opened and poor, resting Rabbie’s head removed. It was sent to Edinburgh for ‘study’. Accurate measurements of the bardie’s skull were taken, and diagrams produced. The results were published in a volume now kept in the Gibson Collection.

The Phrenologists used Burns’ celebrity to attract attention to their studies and to bolster their own credibility, and this marvellous little book in the Gibson collection is testament to that. It’s author, one George Combe, was a principal Scottish phrenologist. Combe’s book does indeed seem credible. Scientific drawings give ‘views of the skull of Robert Burns’, and a little table provides the interested reader with information on the ‘cerebral development of Burns’.

Alistair Heather reads Phrenological Development of Robert Burns by George Combe in the Linen Hall Library.

Whilst the science of phrenology has long since been debunked, this slim volume stands testament to its moment in time. It shows that in 1834 Burns carried sufficient celebrity to make his skull a ‘must have’ item for the nation’s leading scientific enquirers.

The Gibson Collection is outstanding as it allows us to not just get a better understanding of Burns the poet, but also an understanding of Burns the icon, the symbol, the cultural artefact.

Part of the Gibson Collection in the Linen Hall Library.

As Burns’ light has shone out across the world and through time from his Ayrshire base, it’s been refracted in different ways by different cultures. Many, many towns, communities and countries produced their own editions of Burns’ poetry. These were collected up hungrily by Gibson and form part of this tremendous treasure trove. From this we can learn about the types of communities who were engaging with Burns, and when. The affordable early Belfast and Dublin editions for example show a working-class drouth for access to the Bard’s works. Ornate editions with luxury paper and immaculate printing published in the centenary years of his life indicate the esteem in which he was held across the world.

But some of the least expected but most entertaining works in the Gibson Collection are items like the ‘responses’ to Burns. Essays, poetic collections, this phrenological guide, they all help use come to a better understanding of the man through his impact on the world.

Alistair Heather is a writer and presenter, and keen Burns enthusiast from Scotland.

Share via:

Susan Hughes exhibition at The Linen Hall. West Light.

Our June Events at a Glance

WEST LIGHT Exhibition | 02 June – 30 June | 9.30 am – 5.30 pm | Free Susan Hughes presents a series of atmospheric paintings of breeding seabirds including Arctic

Annual General Meeting

The 233rd Annual General Meeting of the Linen Hall Library (Belfast Library and Society for Promoting Knowledge) will be held at 1.00pm on Thursday 25 May 2023 in The Linen

'Origins & Legacies: The Belfast/Good Friday Agreement' project at The Linen Hall.

Origins & Legacies: The Belfast/Good Friday Agreement

To mark the 25th anniversary of the Belfast/Good Friday Agreement, The Linen Hall is launching a new project to explore its origins and legacies. Through an exhibition, a series of events and an oral history project, The Linen Hall will reflect on the processes which led to the accord, the competing sides of the referendum campaign, and its impact.

We are looking for a Library Assistant

The Linen Hall is seeking a full-time, temporary Library Assistant. To apply, please submit a CV with covering letter detailing your experience by email to by Friday 3rd February, at 5 pm.

We are looking for an Archive Project Assistant

‘The Belfast/Good Friday Agreement: Origins and Legacies’ project will explore making, agreeing, and keeping peace in Northern Ireland from the early 1990s until the present day. The project is seeking applications for the role of Archive Project Assistant.